Source: https://mythos-app.download/blog/en-us/did-the-greeks-believe-in-their-gods/

Greek · 6 min read

# Did the Ancient Greeks Believe in Their Gods?

Most Greeks took their gods for granted, but 'belief' is a slippery word. What Xenophanes, Herodotus, Socrates and modern scholars show.

[Back to Stories](https://mythos-app.download/blog/en-us/)

![A farmer leads a garlanded sheep to an open-air altar below a painted temple while a bearded onlooker watches with folded arms.](https://mythos-app.download/images/blog-lt-belief-960.webp)

Yes, for the most part: the ancient Greeks took it for granted that gods existed, and they honoured them in cult every day. But "believe" is a tricky word, because Greek religion had no creed and no church, and scholars still argue about what it meant to acknowledge a god.

## Did any Greek say the gods did not exist?

The earliest famous critic is Xenophanes, a poet-philosopher of the late 6th and early 5th century BCE. His fragments say that Homer and Hesiod gave the gods theft, adultery and mutual deception (DK 21 B11-12). He mocks the idea that gods are born, wear clothes like ours and have human voices and bodies (B14). In B15, probably satirical, horses and oxen would make gods that look like horses and oxen.

That is an attack on how the gods were pictured, not a denial that they exist. The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy describes his theology as "a partial advance toward monotheism." One caution: his words survive only in later authors, so wording and context are second-hand.

The point for our question is that criticism of the poets was already circulating in Greek culture long before Socrates. There was no scripture to defend, so the stories of Homer and Hesiod could be questioned openly.

## What did Herodotus mean by "yesterday or the day before"?

In the *Histories* (2.53), Herodotus says the Greeks did not know where the gods came from, or what they looked like, until "yesterday or the day before." Hesiod and Homer, he says, gave the gods their descent, names, spheres and forms. The twelve figures in [The Twelve Olympian Gods: Who They Are and How They Are Related](https://mythos-app.download/blog/en-us/the-twelve-olympian-gods/) owe much of their familiar shape to those poets.

This is a historical claim about how the pantheon took shape. It is not a sceptic's confession. A review in *Bryn Mawr Classical Review* notes that Herodotus believes the gods personally intervened in the Persian Wars to protect the Greeks. Some scholars, such as Thomas Harrison, argue that Herodotus can think the poets shaped the gods' titles, honours and forms and still treat those portrayals as valid. Others read the line as being specifically about poetic epithets. These readings are debated.

## Did Paul Veyne prove the Greeks did not believe?

No, though the title of his book is often quoted that way. Veyne's *Did the Greeks Believe in Their Myths?* (French original 1983) is about myths, not gods. His example is Theseus. The Greeks knew he had never really killed the Minotaur (see [The Minotaur and the Real Labyrinth of Knossos](https://mythos-app.download/blog/en-us/the-minotaur-and-the-real-labyrinth-of-knossos/)), yet they believed he existed and gave him a genealogy and a place in history. A reviewer in *Philosophy and Literature* sums it up: the Greeks, like us, could believe some parts of a story and disbelieve others.

According to the same review, Veyne's last page answers his own title with "of course they believed." Critics have called the book postmodern or relativist, and Simon Goldhill's 1990 review in *Classical Review* is a good place to start with that debate.

## What was Socrates actually charged with?

In 399 BCE Socrates was indicted for not paying respect to the gods the city respects, introducing new deities, and corrupting the youth (Xenophon, *Memorabilia* 1.1.1; Plato, *Apology* 24b). Only Plato's and Xenophon's accounts of his defence survive. Xenophon suggests the impiety charge grew mainly out of Socrates' claim to a divine "voice" or "sign." That is Xenophon's interpretation.

The key Greek phrase, *theous hous hē polis nomizei ou nomizōn*, is disputed. Does *nomizein* mean "acknowledge that the gods exist," "worship them according to cultic tradition," or "accept them in the normal way"? Robert Parker, H. S. Versnel and David Sedley have each weighed in. In *Apology* 26b-d, Meletus' charge shifts to complete atheism, so the sense of believing that gods exist is plainly in play there. Scholars still dispute how far *nomizein* itself carries that meaning rather than "acknowledge" or "recognise."

One scholarly camp argues the charge was about worship rather than belief. Versnel, who argues that belief mattered, criticises the "fashionable" idea that the Athenians did not believe in their gods. Another camp insists the charge was about belief. A lecture abstract from the Collège de France argues the verb covers both: recognising the gods and paying them due homage, which still does not make the Greeks "believers" in the modern sense.

## Were there other trials for impiety?

Fewer than popular accounts suggest. Jakub Filonik, in a 2013 study of Athenian impiety trials, stresses that most surviving testimony is anecdotal. The trial of Anaxagoras is first mentioned in an extant source by Diodorus Siculus in the 1st century BCE, and later writers disagree about who accused him and what the penalty was. Its date is disputed, with modern scholars proposing dates anywhere from about 450 to 430 BCE (for example 437/6, 434 or 430). The Diopeithes decree against those who did not believe in gods, reported by Plutarch (*Pericles* 32), is doubted by some scholars, who suspect comedy as its source. Protagoras's trial has similar problems.

Words like "atheist" also mislead. *Asebeia* meant impiety and covered action as well as opinion. Diagoras of Melos was probably outlawed and driven from Athens around 415 BCE for it, and later generations made him the atheist par excellence, though the sources are late or hostile and scholars dispute how far he was an atheist at all. The Sisyphus fragment, in which a clever man invents the fear of the gods to deter secret crimes, is given to Critias by Sextus Empiricus and to Euripides in another tradition. A speaker in Euripides' *Bellerophon* denies that gods exist, but that is a character in a play.

## So was Greek religion about practice rather than belief?

Mostly about practice, but not without belief. In the "polis religion" model, Christiane Sourvinou-Inwood argued that the city anchored, legitimated and mediated religious activity, much as the Church does in Christianity. Critics such as Julia Kindt say it neglects religious ideas and discourse. Parker's *Polytheism and Society at Athens* (2005) shows how pervasive cult was, and presents Athenians as both very pious and very down-to-earth. He is no "no belief" scholar.

Plato's *Laws* 10 shows that belief became a live, legislated issue. At 885b the Athenian Stranger names three errors: that the gods do not exist, that they do not care for people, and that offerings and prayers can win them over. Clinias claims all Greeks and non-Greeks believe in gods, yet the passage admits that unbelievers exist. Plato is prescribing a state theology, and his third error condemns ordinary sacrifice and votive religion, so he is a poor witness to everyday practice. For the festivals that shaped public life, see [The Ancient Olympics Were a Festival for Zeus](https://mythos-app.download/blog/en-us/ancient-olympics-festival-for-zeus/), and for one place where gods were consulted, [The Oracle of Delphi: Who Spoke for Apollo?](https://mythos-app.download/blog/en-us/oracle-of-delphi-who-spoke-for-apollo/).

## What we rely on

**Ancient sources**

- Xenophanes, fragments DK 21 B11-12, B14-16 (preserved in later authors; numbering as in the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy).
- Herodotus, *Histories* 2.53.
- Plato, *Apology* 24b and 26b-d; *Laws* 10 (885b); Xenophon, *Memorabilia* 1.1.1.

**Modern scholarship**

- Paul Veyne, *Did the Greeks Believe in Their Myths?*, trans. Paula Wissing (University of Chicago Press, 1988; French original Seuil, 1983).
- H. S. Versnel, *Coping with the Gods: Wayward Readings in Greek Theology* (Brill, 2011).
- Robert Parker, *Polytheism and Society at Athens* (Oxford University Press, 2005).

Want to meet the gods the Greeks argued about, one story at a time? Learn Greek Mythology in Mythos.

[Get the app](https://mythos-app.download/#get-the-app) [See the course](https://mythos-app.download/courses/greek-mythology/)

## Keep reading

- ![A wooden bridal figure in a dress rides on a bullock wagon in a torchlit procession up a hillside.](https://mythos-app.download/images/blog-lt-zeus-hera-960.webp)

  Greek

  October 29, 2026 4 min read

  ### [Why Did Zeus Marry His Sister Hera? What the Sources Say](https://mythos-app.download/blog/en-us/why-did-zeus-marry-his-sister-hera/)

  No ancient writer says why Zeus married Hera. What Hesiod and Pausanias do tell us about the marriage, and what is modern guesswork.

  Read article
- ![Zeus on a rocky mountaintop, with a veiled goddess dissolving into a swirl of mist before him.](https://mythos-app.download/images/blog-lt-metis-960.webp)

  Greek

  October 29, 2026 5 min read

  ### [Why Did Zeus Swallow Metis? Hesiod's Answer and Later Versions](https://mythos-app.download/blog/en-us/why-did-zeus-swallow-metis/)

  Zeus swallowed his first wife Metis to protect his throne. What Hesiod says, where Apollodorus differs, and what scholars add.

  Read article
- ![A white bull wades into a calm sea with a young woman seated on its back, her veil blowing, as her companions watch from the shore.](https://mythos-app.download/images/blog-lt-swan-bull-960.webp)

  Greek

  October 29, 2026 5 min read

  ### [Why Did Zeus Turn Into a Swan and a Bull? What the Sources Say](https://mythos-app.download/blog/en-us/why-did-zeus-turn-into-a-swan-and-a-bull/)

  Zeus appears as a bull to Europa, a swan to Leda and a stream of gold to Danae. What the ancient texts say about why, and what they do not.

  Read article
