Norse · 6 min read

Did the Vikings Really Do the Blood Eagle? What the Sources Say

The blood eagle rests on one ambiguous verse and much later sagas. Here is what each source says and where scholars disagree.

Back to Stories
A carved wooden raven-and-eagle panel on a weathered longhouse wall beside a grey northern shore at dusk.

The blood eagle is not a documented Viking practice. The earliest text is one ambiguous half-stanza from about 1020 to 1038, and the full ritual of cut ribs and drawn-out lungs appears only in much later prose. Scholars still disagree about whether it ever happened.

What is the blood eagle supposed to be?

In the fullest saga versions, a captured enemy is cut open from behind. An eagle shape is carved on his back, the ribs are severed from the spine, and the lungs are pulled out. That is the image most people know.

But the sources do not agree with one another, and the most detailed ones are the latest.

What is the earliest source, and what does it say?

The earliest text is the first stanza of Knútsdrápa, a poem by the Icelandic skald Sigvatr Þórðarson, composed between about 1020 and 1038. That is more than a century and a half after the events it recalls. Matthew Townend's edition of the stanza, in Diana Whaley's volume, translates the line: "And Ívarr, who resided at York, had Ælla's back cut with an eagle."

The Old Norse text is usually printed in a single form, but its meaning is disputed. Editors and scholars have read the syntax in several ways, including "cut with an eagle", "cut by an eagle" and "an eagle cut on Ælla's back." Kock, for example, took ara ("eagle") as accusative: Ívarr "had an eagle cut on Ælla's back." The edition's commentary summarises the debate sparked by Frank, which turns largely on whether skera ("cut") can describe a bird's action.

How did later writers build a ritual from one verse?

The author of Ragnarssona þáttr read the verse as an eagle carved on Ælla's back, then ribs cut from the backbone with a sword and the lungs pulled out. One verb in a poem became a procedure.

SourceWhat it says
Knútsdrápa 1Ælla's back cut "with an eagle" (disputed)
Saxo, Gesta Danorum IXEagle cut in Ælla's back, wound salted
Ragnarssona þáttrEagle, ribs cut with a sword, lungs pulled out
Orkneyinga sagaSame for Hálfdan Háleggr, then given to Odin for victory
HeimskringlaSame event, Einarr acts alone, no Odin
Norna-Gests þáttrThe legendary Lyngvi: back cleft, ribs severed, lungs drawn out

Saxo has no ribs or lungs. He adds that the sons, not content with the wound, also salted the torn flesh, and no other source mentions salt. Reginsmál and Ragnars saga mention only an eagle cut on the back. In Orkneyinga saga, Torf-Einarr has the eagle carved with a sword and the ribs cut from the spine, and offers the man to Odin. Heimskringla has no dedication. Norna-Gests þáttr, probably from the early fourteenth century, applies the rite to Lyngvi, who belongs to legend, not history.

Do English sources mention it?

No. English sources say Ælla and Osberht were killed in battle at York in 867. The Anglo-Saxon Chronicle says "both the kings were slain on the spot", and later accounts such as Symeon of Durham's give the date as 21 March. The Chronicle has no blood eagle. Some websites attribute the saga wording to the Chronicle, which is false.

The revenge story, in which Ragnarr's sons punish Ælla for killing their father, is saga tradition. Dorothy Whitelock doubted that the Ívarr of the sagas can be identified with the Ímar of the Irish annals. Nor did St Edmund die this way: Abbo's Passio has him scourged and shot with arrows, with no eagle. A blood-eagle theory for Edmund is a speculative hypothesis of Alfred Smyth.

Could it be done, and does that settle anything?

In 2022, Luke Murphy and colleagues published an anatomical study in Speculum. They concluded that even the fullest form would have been possible but difficult, and that the victim would probably die early in the process, before the lungs were fully exposed. The popular detail of lungs fluttering like wings while the victim lives on is a modern embellishment, not in the sources.

Feasibility is not proof. The study shows a procedure could be carried out, not that anyone did it. Nor does it show the opposite.

Where do scholars stand?

There are roughly three camps. Roberta Frank (1984) argued that the stanza means Ívarr gave Ælla's body to the eagle as carrion, one of the "beasts of battle" of skaldic poetry, and that later writers took a poetic image literally. She also argued that if the poem cannot support the ritual, it probably never happened, a step that goes beyond the stanza itself.

Her critics, including Murphy and colleagues, think Sigvatr's ambiguity was probably deliberate. Bjarni Einarsson defended the traditional reading from the verse's vocabulary. Alfred Smyth (1977) argued that the blood eagle was a genuine ritual form of slaying, linked to sacrifice, and he disputed Frank's reading. Other scholars have not accepted his case. The Odin link itself appears only in Orkneyinga saga. For the god in question, see Odin Gave an Eye for Wisdom and the hub guide The Norse Gods: Who Is Who in Asgard and Beyond.

A third group calls it possible but unproven. One carving from Stora Hammars I on Gotland seems to show a victim about to be cut open from behind, with a bird of prey behind him. Some link it to the rite, but its interpretation is contested.

In the two best-known cases the victims were noblemen and the killers avenged a murdered father. The Speculum authors suggest the ritual, if real, would fit an honour-based pattern of revenge and elite-focused mutilation of enemies. That too is debated.

What did television add?

In the series Vikings, Ragnar has Jarl Borg killed by the blood eagle, and Ælla suffers it at the hands of Ragnar's sons. The Borg scene is dramatic invention, since he is not among the saga victims. Like the horned helmet in Vikings Never Wore Horned Helmets, the image owes more to later imagination than to the evidence. For another case of screen versus source, see Thor in Myth vs. Thor in the Movies.

What we rely on

Ancient sources

  • Sigvatr Þórðarson, Knútsdrápa 1, ed. Matthew Townend, in Diana Whaley (ed.), Poetry from the Kings' Sagas 1: From Mythical Times to c. 1035 (Brepols, 2012), p. 651.
  • Saxo Grammaticus, Gesta Danorum, Book IX. Translation: Hilda Ellis Davidson (ed.) and Peter Fisher (trans.), Saxo Grammaticus: The History of the Danes (D. S. Brewer, 1979-80).
  • Orkneyinga Saga: The History of the Earls of Orkney, translated by Hermann Pálsson and Paul Edwards (Penguin Classics, 1981).
  • The Anglo-Saxon Chronicle, entry for 867.

Modern scholarship

  • Roberta Frank, "Viking Atrocity and Skaldic Verse: The Rite of the Blood-Eagle," English Historical Review 99 (1984), 332-43.
  • Luke John Murphy, Heidi R. Fuller, Peter L. T. Willan and Monte A. Gates, "An Anatomy of the Blood Eagle: The Practicalities of Viking Torture," Speculum 97.1 (2022), 1-39.

Keep reading